Pace Surpasses Motorola to Take Set-Top Box Lead

Wednesday, May 11th, 2011 
Screen Digest logo

Pace plc (LSE: PIC) of the United Kingdom in 2010 became the world’s No. 1 seller of set-top boxes (STBs) in terms of unit shipments for the first time ever on an annual basis, surpassing Motorola Inc. (NYSE: MMI) of the United States, new IHS Screen Digest research indicates. Pace’s STB shipments surged by 21.1 percent in 2010 to 20.7 million units, up from 17.1 million in 2009. Motorola’s shipments rose only 4.2 percent to 19 million units, up from 18.2 million in 2009.

Top 4 Television Set-top Box Brand Shipment Ranking
(Ranking by Unit Shipments in Millions)

2010                            2010 %age
Rank                2009  2010     Growth
----                ----  ----  ---------
1     Pace          17.1  20.7      21.1%
2     Motorola      18.2  19.0       4.2%
3     Technicolor   12.4  12.9       3.9%
4     Cisco          8.4  11.2      33.2%

Source: IHS Screen Digest May 2011

“Pace’s strong unit shipment growth in 2010 mostly was driven by huge growth in cable shipments to both North and South America,” Morrod said. “Pace has been voraciously taking market share from U.S. incumbents with high-volume deals such as selling boxes to Comcast. The company also fostered new big-volume customers like NET Servi├žos in Brazil.”

Despite Pace’s strong shipment growth, Motorola managed to hold on to the lead in STB revenue. Motorola’s STB revenue amounted to $2.4 billion in 2010, down 9.5 percent from $2.7 billion in 2009. Pace’s revenue rose to $1.9 billion, up 8.1 percent from $1.7 billion in 2009.

Top 4 Television Set-top Box Brand Revenue Ranking
(Ranking by Revenue in Millions of U.S. Dollars)

2010                                2010 %age
Rank                  2009    2010     Growth
----                ------  ------  ---------
1     Motorola      $2,661  $2,409      -9.5%
2     Pace          $1,740  $1,881       8.1%
3     Cisco         $1,424  $1,537       8.0%
4     Technicolor   $1,203  $1,094      -9.0%

Source: IHS Screen Digest May 2011

U.S. STB brands Motorola and Cisco Systems Inc. (NASDAQ: CSCO) have average sales prices (ASP) around 60 percent higher than the European vendors Pace and Technicolor (Paris & NYSE: TCH). However, for all four vendors, ASPs declined by between 2 and 12 percent in 2010.

“The U.S. STB makers command higher ASPs for their STBs than their European rivals because they tend to have more established relationships with the high-volume, advanced cable operators in the Unites States. Both Cisco and Motorola benefit from high ASPs associated with Internet Protocol Television (IPTV) boxes, an area that they dominate,” Morrod said.

Of the 19 million STBs shipped by Motorola in 2010, 5 million were Digital Terminal Adapters (DTAs), which are low-cost set-top boxes that convert digital TV signals to analog. Most of the DTAs were for Comcast’s project Cavalry, which converts analog channels to digital-only delivery in order to reclaim analog spectrum to deliver new services. To give cable customers who don’t have digital service access to programming, Comcast is offering an STB and two DTAs at no additional cost.

Other STB brands also provided DTAs for project Cavalry, including Pace, with 3.5 million units; Technicolor, with 2.5 million; and Cisco, with 1.5 million. Other cable operators, such as Mediacom and Cogeco, are commencing DTA rollouts, indicating that the market opportunity for these low-cost boxes will continue even after the end of Comcast’s project Calvary.

More: Set-Top Boxes Continue to Deliver the Goods–and Pictures–in 2010